Mattress Topper-Pad Reviews & Ratings Summary → Based On Data From Over 27,000 Actual Owners
Page last updated August 16, 2010.
What You Need To Know
Based on data from over 27,000 mattress topper owners, the vast majority (85% overall) say that they are satisfied with their purchase.
The different types of mattress toppers have their own distinct characteristics, advantages and disadvantages that you should know before making a purchase.
Learn about the pros and cons of mattress toppers in general based on owner data.
About Our Research
Our research provides owner experience data on the most popular type of mattress topper -- memory foam -- as well as feather, fiber and latex toppers.
Our research findings are based on reviews / comments of actual mattress pad-topper owners collected from diverse sources. Click here for more information on our research methodology and why it is credible.
Memory Foam Mattress Toppers
Pros
Tend to provide superior pain relief compared to other types; reasonably priced; tend to improve motion isolation; many brands / options to choose from.
Cons
May give off initial odor and act as a heat trap; some varieties may be somewhat difficult to move on.
Read detailed memory foam topper reviews / ratings based on over 24,000 actual owner experiences.
Feather(bed) Mattress Toppers
Pros
Generally effective at softening a firm mattress; few heat problems
Cons
Can lack adequate thickness; fluffing / shaking often needed to maintain loft; feathers poking through cover is possible which can be painful; may be somewhat noisy when lied upon.
Read detailed featherbed topper reviews / ratings based on over 3,500 actual owner experiences.
Latex Mattress Toppers
Pros
Tend to provide good compromise between soft and supportive; above average pain relief; somewhat fewer initial odor and heat trap complaints than memory foam.
Cons
Too firm for some owners; pricey compared to other types; some initial odor possible.
Read detailed latex topper reviews / ratings based on over 280 actual owner experiences.
Fiber(bed) Mattress Toppers
Pros
Generally effective at softening a firm mattress; value; low price; little or no odor
Cons
May be too thin and lumpy for some; shaking / fluffing may be needed to maintain loft and comfort.
Read detailed fiberbed topper reviews / ratings based on over 680 actual owner experiences.
Mattress Topper Comparison
Click on a link in the left column for detailed analysis.
| Latex | ||||
| Number of Owners | 23,234 |
3,509 |
681 |
282 |
| Owner Satisfaction | 88% |
85% |
84% |
84% |
| Better Sleep | Good |
Good-Fair |
Good-Fair |
Good-Fair |
| Less Pain | Good-Excellent |
Fair-Good |
Fair-Good |
Good |
| Firmness | Medium | Soft | Soft | Medium-Firm |
| Durability | Fair-Good |
Good-Fair |
Fair-Good |
Fair-Good |
| Price | $95
avg |
$86
avg |
$48
avg |
$190 avg |
| Value | Good |
Good-Fair |
Good-Excellent |
Fair-Good |
| Takes Getting Used To | Somewhat |
No |
No |
Somewhat |
| Ease of Movement | Fair-Good |
Good |
Good |
Good-Fair |
| Less Tossing/Turning | Good |
Fair |
Fair |
Good |
| No Sleeping Hot | Fair |
Good-Fair |
Good-Fair |
Fair-Good |
| Maintenance | Low |
Medium-High |
Medium |
Low |
| Allergies / Dust Mites | Medium |
Medium |
Medium-High |
Medium |
| No Odor / Off-gassing | Poor-Fair |
Fair-Good |
Good-Excellent |
Fair-Good |
| Stays Secure | Fair |
Fair |
Fair |
Fair |
| Fits Properly | Fair |
Fair |
Fair |
Fair |
| Appearance | Good |
Fair-Good |
Fair-Good |
Good |
| Ease of Cleaning | Fair |
Fair |
Fair |
Fair |